Latest topics
» Polish traditionalists handicapped : Archbishop Lefebvre made a mistake
Wed Nov 15, 2017 8:20 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Communities of Fr.Leonard Feeney in the USA when they interpret Vatican Council II with the irrational premise deny the dogma extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Wed Nov 15, 2017 5:18 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Bishop Robert J.McManus and Brother Thomas Augustine MICM,Superior,St.Benedict Center,Still River,MA, interpret Vatican Council II with the 'possibilites are exceptions' error
Mon Nov 06, 2017 8:47 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» SSPX must be aware of the deception of Abp.Guido Pozzo and confront it
Tue Oct 31, 2017 11:57 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Two popes must ask all Catholics to affirm Vatican Council II (premise-free) as they do
Mon Oct 30, 2017 5:16 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Slaves of the Immaculate Heart of Mary Still River Ma., could lose canomical status because of Feeneyism
Sat Oct 28, 2017 5:54 am by Lionel L. Andrades

»  Traditionalists oppose Pope Francis on morals but give him a pass on salvation
Fri Oct 27, 2017 10:06 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Someone needs to help Cardinal Luiz Ladaria, Archbishop Pozzo and Archbishop Di Noia see how they use a false premise to interpret Vatican Council II
Tue Oct 24, 2017 2:53 pm by Lionel L. Andrades

» Robert Siscoe and John of St. Thomas Respond to Fr. Cekada
Mon Oct 23, 2017 9:25 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Still no denial from Abp.Guido Pozzo : SSPX must accept Vatican Council II with a false doctrine and the new theology based on an irrational premise Image result for Photo of Archbishop Guido Pozzo
Mon Oct 23, 2017 7:03 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Five Catholic academics accept the development of doctrine on salvation and Vatican Council II but reject it on morals and the death penalty
Sun Oct 22, 2017 5:32 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Dr.Robert Fastiggi wants Bishop Donald Sanborn and Chris Ferrara to affirm a magisterium in heresy and schism like him
Sun Oct 22, 2017 5:30 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» ]Christine Niles uses the false premise to interpret magisterial documents
Sat Oct 21, 2017 5:30 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» SSPX has a right to canonical status when they correct their doctrinal error in the 'chart'
Fri Oct 20, 2017 6:25 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» No one shows Massimo Faggioli his precise theological and philosophical mistake
Fri Oct 20, 2017 6:07 am by Lionel L. Andrades

» Rethink "Feeneyism"?
Fri Aug 11, 2017 6:02 pm by tornpage

» Brother Andre Marie MICM, the Prior at the St. Benedict Center does not correct Frs.Brian Harrison and Cekada,Bishops Sanborn,Pirvanus,Kelly and Fellay
Wed Jun 28, 2017 4:24 pm by MRyan

» Revisiting Diocese/Parish Screening Policy
Wed Jun 28, 2017 4:03 pm by MRyan

» When sedes and trads can accept that Pius XII made a mistake then popes since John XXIII are no more in heresy
Wed Jun 28, 2017 3:08 pm by MRyan

» Doctrinal talks were conducted with Fr.Gleize on 'the other side'
Mon Jun 26, 2017 9:08 am by Lionel L. Andrades


Sniping. Is it really moral?

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  pascendi on Wed Feb 20, 2013 7:36 pm

As you all know, Chris Kyle was recently murdered. If you aren't familiar with him, check around a bit. Famous America sniper, wrote a book and stuff, promulgated as an American hero, etc.

I went into a bit of a tyrade recently because Catholics in other places wanted to prop this guy up as a hero, but of course I'm thinking "hey wait a minute, slow down here... sniping... seriously, does this *really* fit squarely within the confines of Catholic morality?"

My Catholic instinct screams out NO. No way.

There's one priest out there, cited in an article by Renew America, who gives argument that Chris was engaged in something within the confines of just war principle. I thought it was a horribly sloppy argument. I can find little else. Some people send me to the CCC claiming that it supports a case for sniping, but I read the sections they provide and find that said sections actually serve to counter their position.

What say you?

pascendi

Posts : 96
Reputation : 102
Join date : 2011-05-19
Location : Forum Founder

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  columba on Thu Feb 21, 2013 2:30 pm

I was listening to an online presentaion a couple of years ago by a British lawyer who was claiming that all those (collectively and individually) involved in military action in foreign countries are war criminals... How so?

Well, according to the Magna Carta (of which both America and Britain are also bound), it would hence forth be considered as War Crime for a sovereign country to invade another sovereign country that had not first been the aggressor. Furthermore (as established at the Nuremberg Trials) it would not be considered as a legitimate defense for a soldier to claim that he was merely following orders if those orders were themselves in breach of the terms of the Magna Carta.

The moral status of the sniper would be irrelevent if the legallity of the war itself is questioned (and has been), which according to the Magna Carta and the UN, America and Britain's Attack on Iraq was illegal, and thus, every soldier who went along with it would himself be guilty of war crime.

I'm not here arguing that the Magna Carta or the UN treaty are the ultimate moral authority; I'm merely stating a fact that those countries who signed to these agreements are morally bound by and judged by them, for better or for worse.

As for Chris Kyle; it may be the case that those who live by the sword, perish by the sword.
avatar
columba

Posts : 979
Reputation : 1068
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Ireland

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  pascendi on Thu Feb 21, 2013 4:44 pm

columba wrote:

As for Chris Kyle; it may be the case that those who live by the sword, perish by the sword.

That was my immediate thought when I first heard of it, right down to the method of execution.

I was meaning to make a distinction between the morality of our involvement in the middle east in general and separate from the narrow consideration of the morality of sniping in as treated uniquely. As for the former, JP2 came out in condemnation of our involvement in the middle east.

Given that our involvement there is itself in question by many as to its legitimacy in regards to just war theory (...theory? really? lol), I figured it only incidental that Chris Kyle sniped in that particular place.

pascendi

Posts : 96
Reputation : 102
Join date : 2011-05-19
Location : Forum Founder

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  columba on Thu Feb 21, 2013 5:21 pm

I must admit to not having gave much thought to the issue of the sniper. What aspect of this method of combat do you consider immoral in a war situation?
avatar
columba

Posts : 979
Reputation : 1068
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Ireland

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  MRyan on Thu Feb 21, 2013 5:46 pm

columba wrote:I must admit to not having gave much thought to the issue of the sniper. What aspect of this method of combat do you consider immoral in a war situation?
Good question.
avatar
MRyan

Posts : 2276
Reputation : 2448
Join date : 2010-12-18

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  MRyan on Thu Feb 21, 2013 5:48 pm

Good article; here’s an extract:

Guilt, Not PTSD, Is What Afflicts Iraq War Veterans
by Jacob G. Hornberger

Consider the following incident related by Kyle, who was one of the U.S. military’s deadliest snipers. Two weeks after he arrived in Iraq, he encountered a woman with a child who pulled a grenade as she was approached by a group of Marines. Kyle shot her dead. He said, “It was my duty to shoot, and I don’t regret it. My shots saved several Americans, whose lives were clearly worth more than that woman’s twisted soul.”

But who here has the twisted soul? That woman was defending her country from the troops of a brutal foreign regime that had unlawfully invaded and occupied her country and killed countless of her countrymen, perhaps members of her family or friends or acquaintances. Kyle was a soldier who had blindly followed the orders of the president to attack, invade, and occupy a country that had never attacked the United States and was killing people who were resisting his aggression.

Ask yourself: What would American men and women do if the United States were attacked, invaded, and occupied by, say, North Korea? Wouldn’t many Americans defend their country, their families, and their homes from the aggressors? Who would Americans consider the twisted souls in that case — the people who were defending or the North Koreans who had attacked, invaded, and occupied the United States?

(http://fff.org/2013/02/05/guilt-not-ptsd-is-what-afflicts-iraq-war-veterans/)
avatar
MRyan

Posts : 2276
Reputation : 2448
Join date : 2010-12-18

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  pascendi on Sun Feb 24, 2013 12:59 am

Good find.

pascendi

Posts : 96
Reputation : 102
Join date : 2011-05-19
Location : Forum Founder

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  Forum Janitor on Sun Feb 24, 2013 5:40 pm

I’m not sure that finding fault with a legitimate act of self-defense, especially when the violent act is being directed against American servicemen, is the way you really want to go here.
avatar
Forum Janitor
Admin

Posts : 235
Reputation : 565
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Forum Janitor

http://catholicforum.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  columba on Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:30 pm

Forum Janitor wrote:I’m not sure that finding fault with a legitimate act of self-defense, especially when the violent act is being directed against American servicemen, is the way you really want to go here.

I would like to think that "legimate" acts of self-defense are the right of all (not just Americans or western Europeans). The morality of the use of snipers was being questioned and I was wondering what the argument against their use would be in a legitimate war situation. I'm still not sure what the arguments for or against are.
avatar
columba

Posts : 979
Reputation : 1068
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Ireland

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  Forum Janitor on Sun Feb 24, 2013 11:38 pm

A sniper is a specialist job in the military to augment the effectiveness of a formation, to harass the enemy’s ability to operate, and provide a screen to impede the enemy’s ability to decipher friendly movements, and on the other hand, to provide intelligence about the enemy’s movements.

In this case, a sniper engaged an enemy target which was attempting to attack US Forces. He was well within his rights to do so, and there are probably some men alive today in that case, who were able to complete their jobs and go home to their families thanks to his efforts.
avatar
Forum Janitor
Admin

Posts : 235
Reputation : 565
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Forum Janitor

http://catholicforum.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  RememberGethsemane on Mon Feb 25, 2013 3:41 am

Just signed in today after a long absence to reply to this vomit about chris kyle, and it reminded me why i left this place of vomit in the first place. Chris Kyle got celebrity status after writing a book of lies about his so called heroic events in Iraq, he said he punched out Jesse Ventura in a bar because he was downing marines etc which was proved lies. Kyle was a killing machine lunatic and mind-controlled, the invasion of Iraq was an act of rape by America and a disgrace to their country. To hold anyone who took part in that dispecable act in any sort of esteem is abhorrent and I now know that the participants in this room are vile, because they dont have the basic intelligence of morality. Anyone who takes part in conversations justifying the basic satanic agenda is scum.

RememberGethsemane

Posts : 86
Reputation : 92
Join date : 2012-04-26

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  RememberGethsemane on Mon Feb 25, 2013 3:56 am

May Saint John the apostle favored by Christ fervored in his love for Christ and His Mother open your eyes to Truth.

RememberGethsemane

Posts : 86
Reputation : 92
Join date : 2012-04-26

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  RememberGethsemane on Mon Feb 25, 2013 4:06 am

Forgive me Lord my trespasses against You, I am not worthy of You.

RememberGethsemane

Posts : 86
Reputation : 92
Join date : 2012-04-26

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  Forum Janitor on Mon Feb 25, 2013 10:39 am

There really isn’t a good reply to all of that.
avatar
Forum Janitor
Admin

Posts : 235
Reputation : 565
Join date : 2010-12-18
Location : Forum Janitor

http://catholicforum.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Re: Sniping. Is it really moral?

Post  Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum